The ETF Sales Pitch
Seemingly each fund management company has come out of the woodwork with ETFs that are supposed to provide traders with an easy means of investing in just about any particular market field, index or even themes.
Over the past several months, these types of supposedly index-linked investment automobiles have been repackaged – and with the permission of US regulators, have become so flexible and in some cases handled – that they’re not even listed to anything.
And whether an ETF is linked to an index or not, it can of course also apparently be created to perform at a multiple of an underlying container of securities or catalog – or, even to perform in the opposite direction.
Billions upon billions of dollars have been spent on advertising and pitches to buy into this particular supposedly new form of investing.
The idea is that rather than having to actually pick out shares to buy or sell — you can just buy an ETF and have it all done for a person.
And, so the pitches go, ETFs are really much cheaper than investing in a shared fund – closed finish or open end — because all the managers have to do is put together the ETF based on an index and let the market price them. So, it’s almost like investing for free.
No wonder that so many traders – even supposed experts – buy and keep ETFs across many marketplaces. Because (if you take the sales literature at encounter value) they’re cheap, easy and the modern way to run a profile.
Except that they may not.
What the Pitchmen Don’t Tell You
To understand the reason why, let’s look first at the core of what makes for an ETF.
An trade Traded Fund might have a great name on the outside – but most investors will never, ever be able to find out what’s actually inside them.
That’s because the folks that build and operate ETFs will only release elaborate really in them to the professional traders that sign on to make markets in them.
While ETFs trade upon exchanges and folks think that they may buying or selling at the net resource values of the moment — the truth can be far and away various.
That’s due to the fact throughout the day, few folks really know what’s inside the ETF’s underlying assets, which are put by what are called “Creation models. ” Each Creation device is what is used to deliver a good ETF share to the marketplace.
And, every share of an ETF actually is just a share in the fundamental real basket of property.
Those assets can vary widely throughout the trading day and are not usually made up of real stock shares – but rather a series of options, swaps, ahead and a host of some other derived securities, in quantities and proportions that only the particular specialists and the managers of the ETF know about.
Traders in the know love these things because they get to trade against the underlying basket of property. They get to buy, market, short and everything else that can enable them to arbitrage against the secret baskets of property behind every ETF.
So, while you might think that you are buying or selling an ETF at the real value of the particular index that it’s supposed to be linked to – you really will never, actually know for sure.
And when it comes to markets not really priced up to the moment – state, foreign stocks or provides – not only do you have the particular uncertainty of the underlying devious mix of derivatives that really back up an ETF, but you also have the uncertainty of what the supposed basket of property might be priced at.
In past years, i have seen some Asian ETFs trade at premiums plus discounts amounting to over 30 percent away from what should be their own real market prices.
So, not so simple, are they?
But it gets worse.
Severe Underperformance Against standards and Alternative Vehicles
While the shows of ETFs can monitor underlying indexes – they often underperform. And when you match up many ETFs against closed end funds focused on the same or even very similar markets, ETFs tend to lag.
1 prime example can be seen in the past recommendation in the b razil market that worked out quite well for my subscribers years ago. I recommended buying plus owning a closed-end fund called The Brazil Fund for years — selling it in 2006. the particular returns for that fund, kept for 5 years, had been just shy of three hundred percent.
right now, if you had been reading the stuff back then, and instead of buying my fund recommendation, proceeded to go along with an ETF apparently tracking the Brazilian marketplace trading as the Brazil iShare – you would have made cash – but with less than half of the return of the fund and the market.
this particular lag in performance will be bad enough for non-leveraged ETFs – but can get even worse for leveraged ETFs and more so for ETFs that will supposedly move in an reverse fashion to an underlying catalog or basket of property.
Another foe of ETFs: Time
The key for all of the ETFs is that the longer the period of time you look at their overall performance, the worse they match up against their objectives. If you were to look at any of the above ETFs on any given day, there is a greater propensity for them to monitor what they’re supposed to monitor. But as you move out through 1 day to 2 times and so on – the relationship begins to break down very quickly.
The lesson here is that ETFs can make for excellent trading fodder for those who are privy to the real underlying asset mix of the underlying creation shares. which how – and by who – real money is made within ETFs.
For the rest of us mere mortals, we would all be better served in order to steer our portfolios away from the pitches of Wall Street and instead follow the move by one of the biggest creators of ETFs — Barclays – which earlier this year dumped its ETF account operations.
Neil George is publisher of the weekly ezine simply by George: Profits Hidden in the News. He is also editor of the website Stocks That Pay You, which is devoted to finding high-dividend stocks, bonds and other investments that possess a high degree of safety. Neil is a brutal advocate for first choosing higher-yielding securities, then reducing his recommendations to only all those companies which can pass their stringent, proprietary financial tension tests.
Understanding VIX contango plus ETF leverage can save you a small fortune.
Video Rating: five / 5
